Withdraw
the FII Label
We are a campaign led by survivors, clinicians, social workers and academics
An Open Letter...
We call for:
-
Immediate withdrawal of the FII label and associated guidance
-
Creation of new, evidence-based frameworks co-produced with disabled people and parent carers
-
Professional training that promotes collaborative, family-centred practice, and understanding of disability and distress
-
A review by regulatory bodies—including the GMC, Royal Colleges, and NICE—of any guidance legitimising the use of FII
-
Judicial caution in accepting FII allegations without rigorous factual analysis and greater scrutiny of expert witness testimony
Recent coverage in The Sunday Times has exposed the devastating consequences of misidentifying parents - mostly mothers - as fabricating or inducing illness in their children.
It told the stories of Ella, who was separated from her mother for eight months and placed with untrained carers who failed to meet her complex needs, and Melody, whose mother watched her die in pain after medication was withdrawn during an FII investigation. We know of many more such cases. These are not abstract tragedies—they are direct, preventable outcomes of acting on flawed guidance.
FII is not a medical diagnosis.
It has no agreed criteria, no reliable method of identification, and no robust evidence base. Yet guidance intended to protect is instead causing harm— particularly to disabled and neurodivergent children with complex needs. Parents are increasingly suspected of fabrication not because of evidence, but because they persist in seeking answers, disagree with professionals, or challenge misdiagnoses. Advocacy is being pathologised.
We acknowledge that in a very small number of cases, illness may be fabricated or induced by a parent or carer. These are extremely rare and should be treated as either criminal matters or mental health concerns, using established safeguarding, forensic, or psychiatric pathways. They do not require a vague and misapplied label like FII.
A review of Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews in England (2010–2021) identified only four cases of serious harm due to confirmed fabrication or illness induction—none involving a child’s death. In contrast, hundreds of families report lasting trauma following false FII accusations: delayed treatment, forced separation, exclusion from services, and fear of seeking help again—even in emergencies.
This is not safeguarding.
It is systemic harm
The Hard Truth
Who we are...
Giving a voice to organisations and 424 individuals including 176 with lived experience
(last updated 28th May)
Elizabeth Archer, CEO, PDA Society.
Dr Ana Laura Aiello, Cerebra Postdoctoral Researcher, University of Leeds.
Dr Andy Bilson, Emeritus Professor of Social Work, University of Central Lancashire
Paul Bywaters Emeritus Professor University of Huddersfield.
Jess Camburn-Rahmani, CEO, Cerebra
Elly Chapple, mother, founder of FlipTheNarrative
Sonya Chowdhury, Chief Executive, Action for ME.
Luke Clements, Cerebra Professor of Law & Social Justice, the University of Leeds.
Taliah Drayak, Co-Founder of Society for Family Preservation, Research Fellow, Department of Public Health, University of Cambridge
Sian Erickson, MSC SCPHN, Co Chair PFAN.
Dr Judy Eaton, Consultant Clinical Psychologist, Help for Psychology Services
Laura Ferguson, Independent researcher in autism and parental blame.
Lucy Fullard, CEO Parent and Carer Alliance CIC
Emma Gant, Safety First Wales.
Claire Glasman, WinVisible (women with visible and invisible disabilities).
Amy Griffiths, BA Hons, LLM (Human Rights Law), PhD Research Candidate (Public Health), Swansea University
Dr Fiona Gullon-Scott, Senior Lecturer in Clinical Psychology, Newcastle University.
Beverley Hitchcock, Director of Research & Support Services, Cerebra
Debbie Hollingsworth, Independent researcher in autism and parental blame.
Donna Kelso, Voice for Change Staffordshire
Cathleen Long, independent social worker, lead author BASW guide on FII
Tammy Mayes, Former co-chair of PFAN
Fiona MacLeod, Advisory Project Manager PAN Cymru.
Amanda Maguire Founder of Neurodiverse Adventures
Andy McDonnell CEO Studio3
Emma McGinnis, Lecturer, Ulster University, and co-chair PFAN.
Anne Neale, Support Not Separation
Tracey Norton, Disabled Mothers’ Rights Campaign
Sally Russell OBE, Trustee PDA Society
Jacqui Shurlock, Chief Executive, Challenging Behaviour Foundation
Diana Skelton, Head of Giving Poverty a Voice Programme, ATD Fourth World.
Dr David Thorpe, Emeritus Professor of Applied Social Science, University of Lancaster
Dr Adrian Tookman, Chairman Forgotten Patients Overlooked Diseases and Retired
Palliative Medicine Physician
Chrissa Wadlow Founder & Managing Director, Sunshine Support
Renata Watts, Co-Director, Special Needs Jungle
Dr David Wilkins, Professor of Social Work, Cardiff University
Emma Williams, Independent Child Protection
Added via this website:
Miriam Bayliss
Jane Harris
Lucy Smith
Louise Drake
Bansi Shah
Dr Arosha fernando
Charlotte Mayou Lynham
Sam Dias
Cee
Adam
L Ward
Karen Böhr
Laura Goodall
Clare Lucignoli
Dawn Sharples
Claire Rutter
SEA Robin
Claire Davies
Karl Davies
Nramage
MLamont
NLamont
Lindsay Williams
jordan eglintine
Jessie Smith-Tahir
Rachel Gavin
Lynne Challener
Graham hughes
Ashley challener
Mitchell Hughes
Elysia welvaert
Chloe hughes
Tiffany Hughes
Beryl Challener
Marc Challener
Sarah
Hayleyyy
Amy
Stacey
Ella
Dexter
Oscar
Arlo
Mrs Gillian Mead
T dolan
Z falconer
Kae Fairhill
Sarah-Jane Onken
Nicole Jayne Brennand
Katherine Burns
Debs shine
Stephanie
Benjamin Winfield
S Burchill
Natasha dance
Rebecca Louise
Carol Stott PhD
Amy Kirkham
Michelle Holloway
Craug
Jade Delta
Susan Madon
Dean Mason
John Mason
Luke Mason
Jean Perry
Joanne Luongvan
Sandra Thomas
Dewi Thomas
Samantha Claridge
FIONA CONNOR
L. Brittain
Kathryn Curtis
Charlea Lewis
Elaine McMillan
PG
LG
Helen McLaren
Liz McPherson
Kirsteen Allan
Ianthe Campion
Jess Hawkins
Lauren Connolly
T Pain
Julia Caro
Aimi Lacanivalu
Tilly Hodgson
Sarah Clark
Bethan McDonald
Sarah Perring
Liberty Rebel
Anna F
Jen Evans
Jenny Hedges
ML Cosgrove
WP Cosgrove
JWPC
Tee Butler
Jordan Andrews
Alex Andrews
Patricia Calloway
Pixie Tenenbaum
Alex Curtis
Opium Field
Bryony Carter
H Hart
WMH
SH
C. Mansfield
julia
Janet Brooksbank
Chrispy freshfern
Kerri Page
Colby Davis
PrincessDisney
Alison Ryan
Katie Gittins
M Evans
Ange Spencer
Claire
Steven
Gillian Crea
Rachel Kirkham
Martin Evans
Margaret Roberts
Lucy Montgomery
Sophie Pumfrey
Sarah Shaw
Wayne Shaw
Julie Haystead
Carol Binks
Jeanette Harris
Helen Coney
Deborah Bircham
Irene Thorpe
Gin Lang
Magenta 737
Wendy Boutilier
Hippymum1963
Deborah Connoley
Naomi Atticus
Laura Thomas
Jennifer Wilson
Helen Gibson
Paula Windsor
Emma mannings
Joanne Barnwell
M field
Michiel van Zanten
Virginia Bell
Renata Ralph
Fiona MacLean
Lisa Hannah
Holly
Eleanor Spencer
Tuva Maria Martinussen
Caroline Fricker
Mr and Mrs P van Dyck
Leonie Potgieter
JanetM
David Griffin
Julie fitch
Andrea Spain
Anne Donovan
Chris Wunderlin
Lynne hughes
Louise Parker Engels
Clare Greenaway
Rebecca Freckleton
Mark Harper, Chair, Cambridgeshire ME and LC Support
Henry Anderson
Joan Crawford
Robert Barr
Helen Luck
Cecilia
Janice Watkins
Sarah miller
Dawn Shimmield
Caroline Li
Anne Ball
Laura Whittington
Jenny mcevoy
Michelle Bourlet
Suzanne waller
Sophie Watkins
Daisy
Louise Coles
H Curtis
Jana Touati
Kathye King
Kayla
Angela (Wood) Favell
Becky Harrison
Sharon evans
Lisa Newman
Bonnie Patton
Demita Laza
Daniel Lee Clements
Peter Kemp
Grace Porter
Lynne B
Pippa Michele Leeson
Jenny L
Ginny Peszynska
Emma Iraci
mmt
Unique - Rare Chromosome Disorder Support Group
Krystal Gault
Peter Wobser
Jaki
Gemma Long
Alison Harrison
Victoria Murtagh
Rachel Lauder
Lea Hayes
Sue Bergstrom
Ceri Jones
Dr Georgie Siggers, Consultant Paediatrician, FRCPCH
Lucia Ciampa
Artis Grace
Lisa duncan
Becky Mulholland
Tara Anderson-Myrie
Laura Howarth
Jane Bucknall
Megan Jones
Steph
Gene People
J L
Rachael Walkingshaw-McGuinness
Sharon Byrne
A. Parent
My’relle Morris
Nick Greer
Rosanna Wregor
Rosie Barrett
Susan Greenwood
ChaNan Bonser
Dr Asad Khan
Hayley Bright
Dr Jo Greer, Educational Psychologist
Kylie sidney
Trish Rochr
Melissa Davies
Chris Ternent
Laura Osborne
Kerry Hodgson
Davy Charleson
Maria Sale
Pat
Lisa Whitehouse
Jac Co
Linda Hending
Nicky Proctor
J Simpson
Susan Worrall
AC
Dr Jean McDonald
Long Covid Advocacy
Rwth Leach
Lucy Forth
Julia Lamb Tod
Peter Hardman
Gill Ray
Femke
Pauline Packer
Betty Ellery
R Lloyd-Jones
L Coates
Katherine Mansfield
ME/CFS patient
James Moffett
Catherine McLoughlin
Maria Flynn
Mair Squire
Rosie
H. Lama
Helen Lama
Marie Patricia Barnfield
Carol Fido
Rebecca Gurry
Kirstin Highins
Stephanie Franz
Julia McCaully
Anne Nicholls
Rocio Castillero
EK
Natalie slack
Rebecca H
Theresa Ryley
Lorraine Brandon
Mika Rowan
Amanda
Christiane Fischer
Morna Blake
Elaine Baskerville
Michael Natt
Peter Trewhitt
W. Nethercott
Nichola McPaul
Netwilf
Anna-Karin
Libby B
Scapegoaters go unpunished
Estelle Mitchell
Maddison Nixon
Jane Field
Joe Wood
Kate Spain
A Campbell
Kelvin clarke
Dr Rosemary Fearnley
Susan
J Raven
Rachel Elliott
Alexis Bushnell
Evelyne Sassoon
Jack Lean
Keren Smith
Emma
Anita Mir
Hazel Green
ZP
Takia
Saika
Billy
AGKHAN
Annaliese Ellis
Pamela Hatcher
Caron Kipping
Emma m
Natalie Shepherd
Candice Mc
J.S.
Jenny Wilson
Rosie Smith
Joanna Holt
K Flanagan
Kath Frame
Jas Frame
Chloe Frame
Ellie Frame
Nicola Guy
Joanne Roper
Amy holt
Prisca MacDonald
1st violin
Abigail Purkis
Betty Green
Kim Jarred
Denise Ives
Gemma Venn
Kate Steel
Sandra valmary
E Neale
Louise Fox
Traudel Eiler
Sarah Russell
Mrs Tamille Steadman
Charlotte
Sophie Mitchell
Claire Kitchen
Jay Looker
Paul Van Dorp
Judith Stark
Wendy Godden
Avril
Kathryn Lucas
Serena Dawson
Ali D
Clare McGinty
Sarah Mackenzie
Karen Tye-Walker
Kat Gillett
Sheila Skinner
Lindy
Rachel L
Dawn Salter
Helen Horsley
Amy Davison
Victoria Bunn
Christine Kendall
Louise Bentham
Kate King
Rebecca Stephens
Sophie
Luke M
Contact us
Your details will be kept secure and if you have a question, we will reply soon.
-
If you confirm you would like to sign the open letter, your name will be added to the public signature list.
-
If you allow us to use your story, we may quote you but will not make any personal details public without asking your permission.
-
Your email will not be shared, and will only be used to reply to your contact, to ask permission, and for updates if you wish.
Organisations
Action for ME
Cerebra
Challenging Behaviour Foundation
Disabled Mothers’ Rights Campaign
FlipTheNarrative
Forgotten Patients: Overlooked Diseases
Parents, Families and Allies Network
Safety First Wales
Society for Family Preservation